What Neighbors PaidShare a priceShare what you paid

Every price is either submitted anonymously to What Neighbors Paid or documented from a public source. Nothing here is a quote or professional advice.

AboutHow our data worksCitiesEditorial policyContactAPITermsPrivacy

Home / Water Heater Replacement / IL / Chicago

Water Heater Replacement Cost in Chicago, IL

Browse every full price guide for Chicago

3 reports so far. Full price stats appear at 8.

We only show medians and price charts once there’s enough data to be trustworthy. Every report gets Chicago closer.

Add what you paid

Reports so far

Prices marked with a source link were documented from a public post; you can open the original and read the quote. The rest were submitted anonymously here.

  • $1,650Aug 2026reddit Aug 2026 ↗
    Read the quote

    “I paid $1650 in Chicago recently from a licensed plumber who is not cheap.”

  • $2,500Mar 2026reddit Mar 2026 ↗
    Read the quote

    “Wow the burbs are expensive. We put a 1.6 gps tankless in last summer. Installed it was $2500 and I thought that was high.”

  • $5,949Mar 2026reddit Mar 2026 ↗
    Read the quote

    “We did this last year. Replaced two old water heaters with a single tankless. I paid $5949 for a Navien tankless system through Legendary Service, very happy with it. Gas bills…”

What drives the price of Water Heater Replacement

Water-heater replacement starts with tank capacity or, for tankless units, required flow rate and temperature rise. Fuel type matters because gas, electric resistance, heat-pump, and tankless heaters need different venting, wiring, gas supply, clearances, and drainage. Moving the heater, changing its type, or installing it in an attic can turn a straightforward swap into plumbing, electrical, and carpentry work.

A surprisingly large share of the bill can be code upgrades. A replacement may require a thermal expansion tank, drain pan and drain line, seismic strapping in some states, new shutoff valves, vent changes, a gas sediment trap, or a dedicated electrical circuit. Tankless conversions may also require a larger gas line, new exhaust routing, condensate handling, and annual flushing provisions.

More Chicago prices

  • Furnace Replacementmedian $5,000 · 11 reports
  • Window Replacementmedian $12,500 · 11 reports
  • Tree Removalcollecting · 3 so far
  • Pet Dental Cleaningcollecting · 3 so far
  • Deep House Cleaningcollecting · 2 so far
  • HVAC / A/C Replacementcollecting · 1 so far
  • Local Movecollecting · 1 so far
  • Sewer Line Repair / Replacementcollecting · 1 so far